News

Pamela Sneed

Keisha Scarville

4Columns

4/18/2025

322 Ways of Looking at a Father: in an ongoing series, the artist experiments with embellishment and transmutation of a passport photo.

At this time in the United States, the Trump regime is aggressively and narrowly redefining notions of nationhood and citizenship. The government is using the Alien Enemies Act, previously invoked specifically in wartime, to deport anyone labeled as a threat to America, without due process, without respect for freedom of speech. Many of us on the left, including writers and artists, are living in shock and in fear of an administration that violates visas and green cards, documents that secure passage, standing, and legality in a foreign country. We are witnessing daily a kind of targeting, violence, and xenophobia that has only ever led to the grimmest of outcomes in world history. In this context, photographer and artist Keisha Scarville’s Passports 2012–2025, at Higher Pictures in Dumbo, couldn’t be more salient. The exhibition consists of 322 images, digital reproductions of a passport photo of the artist’s father, taken at the age of sixteen, that he had gifted to his daughter.

Scarville’s father migrated from Guyana to the United States in the late 1960s. The series began in 2012 and was prompted by a conversation the photographer had with him. She asked if he would ever consider returning to Guyana. He answered, “No, I’m an American now.” What ensues, then, with the artist’s ongoing practice, is a process of transformation based on the passport photo. It is an interrogation of what it has meant for her father to leave his country of origin and to become someone essentially viewed as a Black American. The collection explores her father’s identity, his travels, his transformation, transmutation, assimilation, and the many possibilities exhibited by various personas. With collage, painting, assemblage, and possibly sculpture, and materials like gold paint, glitter, beads, puzzle pieces, found images, and thread, Scarville embellishes her father’s image. It is the kind of shape-shifting associated with aliens or entities in science fiction, or with deities that occupy the spirit realm, gesturing toward Afrofuturism.

The work calls to mind the medical textbook collages of Wangechi Mutu, Lorna Simpson’s collages of Black femme and male images from vintage Ebony and Jet magazines, and the Calling Card series of Adrian Piper, to name a few. I am reminded, too, of the West African Orishas, who in some stories are said to have traveled with the slaves on ships to the new world. They act as guides, protectors, teachers, agitators, and here can offer justice and solace. They can also be mischief-makers. There is quite a bit of mischief and play in Scarville’s hand, as well. Her father is at times a superhero with bat ears and at other times a saint. He wears an Afro, dons masks and disguises; he is a man, a boy, a woman, with images from pop culture and African American histories embedded into and around his face. Scarville has said she wanted to trouble the neutralized passport picture and offer a series of interventions to the static, dispassionate image.

For many who have traveled for any length of time or are immigrants, we know there can be a freedom in unburdening ourselves from the past—a chance at reinvention. In addition, there can be a steep loss. Sometimes these states coexist. In one particularly striking image, the father’s face is scratched out, mimicking the violent erasure that can be part of immigration. I think through a daughter’s continuous ritual; her practice becomes an act of devotion, prayer, commemoration, demonstrating a connectedness to home. The artist is performing a kind of archaeology, a digging with one’s hands, an excavation of history. Ultimately, it is a form of preservation. The show is not ordered chronologically but intuitively arranged. Its layout could be considered a road, linear at the outset, but in the second room exploding into worlds, constellations, and possibilities. The viewer’s eyes travel from piece to piece through materials and arrangements. For me, it becomes music, jazz, riffing, and scatting. Each image is a key. There is also a longing present. In one picture, song lyrics that I recognize surround her father’s face. They are by Otis Redding: “I’ve been loving you too long . . .”

I am struck by quite a few of the artist’s works, such as one where an image is halved and then repaired by a line of gold glitter. There are repetitions of the colors red, black, and green, an ode to her father’s position in Guyana as a Pan-Africanist, a Garveyite in opposition to the British colonization that ended in 1966. Flags and stars are a refrain, as well as dots that could be interpreted as rain, or curtains. I think of sea urchins. Scarville has stated her father loved to swim in the sea. In one arresting image, a puzzle piece is collaged over her father’s face, which speaks metaphorically to the ideas of clues and searching. I discovered it is a piece from a puzzle of Black Caribbean film star Sidney Poitier, who represented Hollywood and the American dream to many Blacks of the diaspora.
Admittedly, before this show, I knew very little about Guyana in South America. I’d only ever heard of it in relation to the 1978 Jonestown massacre, a tragic story of many Black people who followed the American cult leader Jim Jones to Guyana in hopes of building a utopia without the perils of racism and classism in the US. Their endeavor turned deadly, a mass suicide. In some ways, Scarville’s exhibit counters that scene. We are shown the face of an individual Black man, who is not trapped, but chooses to leave Guyana. He expresses agency and is in charge of his destiny. It is a singular face, not a mass of people in a blurred photo. The intimacy expressed in the portrait of a father by his artist daughter adds a necessary humanism and humanity.

What I find unique about Keisha Scarville’s oeuvre is her hand. It is never mechanical, there is always a tenderness and charged tactility. Additionally, at the core of this beautiful show is an irony, a duality on display, that a small, palm-size portrait could have such monumental purpose, meaning, and implication outside of its official use.

https://www.4columns.org/sneed-pamela/keisha-scarville